
Keating Hotel
Best for downtown walkability, nightlife, and a compact boutique stay in the Gaslamp Quarter.
Prices in other currencies are estimates. You’re charged in USD.
Keating Hotel is a small, design-forward boutique in San Diego’s Gaslamp Quarter good for travelers who want downtown nightlife, walkability, and a historic setting. Coronado Island Marriott Resort & Spa is a large branded waterfront resort on Coronado Island that suits guests seeking resort amenities (pools, full spa) and bayfront access.
Updated · about 3 km apart (across San Diego Bay)

Best for downtown walkability, nightlife, and a compact boutique stay in the Gaslamp Quarter.

Best for resort-style amenities, multiple outdoor pools, tennis and a full-service spa on Coronado Island.
When Keating Hotel wins: Choose Keating if you want to be in the middle of downtown San Diego — steps from restaurants, nightlife, Petco Park and the Convention Center — and prefer a small historic boutique with Pininfarina design touches.
When Coronado Island Marriott Resort & Spa wins: Choose the Marriott if you want resort facilities (three outdoor pools, tennis courts, a full-service spa), bayfront views and easier access to Coronado Beach and seaside activities. It’s a better pick for meetings and large events thanks to extensive conference space.
Bottom line: Keating is a compact boutique for downtown-focused travelers; Coronado Island Marriott Resort & Spa is a larger branded waterfront resort for guests who prioritize pools, spa and resort programming. Pick based on whether you want downtown walkability (Keating) or resort amenities and beach access (Marriott).
| Category | Keating Hotel | Coronado Island Marriott Resort & Spa |
|---|---|---|
| Overall vibe | Small boutique, historic building with Italian Pininfarina design | Branded waterfront resort with resort and conference facilities |
| Location | Gaslamp Quarter, downtown San Diego—walkable to Petco Park and Convention Center | Coronado (Bayside) on Coronado Island with bay views and short drive/ferry to downtown |
| Size | 35 rooms (about 4 floors) | 300 guestrooms |
| Ages / policy | All-ages property (hotel policy allows children) | |
| Pools & beach | No on-site pool | Three outdoor pools; beach access nearby (Coronado Beach) |
| Restaurants & bars | No on-site full restaurant (hotel directs guests to Gaslamp dining) | On-site dining including ALBACA poolside restaurant, bar/lounge, room service |
| Spa & wellness | In-room and in-suite spa/massage services; Fresca Spa Suite for dedicated in-suite spa | Full-service spa with massages, body treatments and facials; health club, yoga/Pilates options |
| Meetings & events | ~2,500 sq ft historic event space with several small meeting rooms (Gran Turismo, Maranello, Modena) | ~7,455 sq ft of conference space and 20 meeting rooms |
| Parking & access | Valet parking (in/out) with height restrictions; central downtown transit and trolley access | Self and valet parking (fees), limo/town car service, concierge; closer to Coronado attractions |
| Notable extras | Design-led rooms, Kerstin Florian bath products, complimentary Wi‑Fi, boutique-sized service | Boat tours, kayak/windsurfing/water activities on site, electric car charging, extensive meeting facilities |
Keating sits in the heart of the Gaslamp Quarter at 432 F Street, within walking distance of major downtown spots.
Choose Keating if you want to be steps from downtown attractions, dining and nightlife.
Coronado Island Marriott sits bayside on Coronado Island at 2000 2nd St, a short drive or ferry ride from downtown San Diego.
Pick the Marriott for bayfront location and easy access to Coronado Beach and island sights.
Keating offers 35 custom-designed loft-style rooms and suites called stanzas, many with Pininfarina-inspired touches.
Rooms are compact, design-forward and suited to travelers who value style and location over resort-scale variety.
Coronado Island Marriott has about 300 guestrooms across a range of room types, many with resort or bay views.
The Marriott offers a wide range of room choices and room views typical of a large waterfront resort.
Keating does not operate a full on-site restaurant and refers guests to Gaslamp Quarter dining nearby.
If on-site dining matters, Keating relies on surrounding neighborhood choices.
Coronado Island Marriott provides multiple on-site dining options including a poolside restaurant and bars.
Marriott is stronger for guests who want on-site dining and poolside service.
Keating focuses on boutique urban stays and does not have an on-site pool.
Keating is not a pool or beach resort—it’s a downtown boutique for exploring San Diego on foot.
Pools and bay activities are a key part of the Marriott experience, with three outdoor pools and multiple watersports options nearby.
Marriott is the clear choice for guests prioritizing pools and waterfront recreation.
Keating offers in-room spa and a specialty Fresca Spa Suite; nightlife is the surrounding Gaslamp Quarter.
Keating’s wellness options are in-room; the neighborhood supplies nightlife.
The Marriott provides a full-service spa, fitness and organized wellness activities alongside on-property evening dining and bars.
Marriott offers resort-level wellness and evening amenities for guests staying on property.

Keating — steps from Gaslamp restaurants, bars and entertainment; no need to drive.

Coronado Island Marriott Resort & Spa — three outdoor pools, poolside dining and direct access to bay activities and Coronado Beach.

Coronado Island Marriott Resort & Spa — larger meeting inventory (20 meeting rooms, 7,455 sq ft conference space) for bigger groups.

Keating — occupies an 1890 historic building redesigned by Pininfarina with 35 individually styled rooms.
Keating Hotel — it sits in the Gaslamp Quarter within easy walking distance of restaurants, bars, Petco Park and the convention center.
Coronado Island Marriott Resort & Spa — it’s on Coronado Island and much closer to Coronado Beach than a downtown hotel.
Keating does not have a pool and offers in-room spa services; Coronado Island Marriott Resort & Spa has three outdoor pools and a full-service spa.
Coronado Island Marriott Resort & Spa — it offers significantly more conference space and meeting rooms than Keating’s smaller historic event venues.
Explore how Keating Hotel stacks up against other hotels nearby:
vs. sites like Expedia, Hotels.com and other OTAs ·