
Keating Hotel
Best for couples and solo travelers who want a compact, stylish downtown base steps from nightlife, Petco Park, and the convention center.
Prices in other currencies are estimates. You’re charged in USD.
Keating Hotel is a design-forward boutique in the Gaslamp Quarter for travelers who want downtown walkability and historic character. Hyatt Regency Mission Bay Spa and Marina is a four-star marina resort on Mission Bay for guests who want waterfront pools, on-site spa services, and resort-style amenities.
Updated

Best for couples and solo travelers who want a compact, stylish downtown base steps from nightlife, Petco Park, and the convention center.

Best for travelers seeking resort-style pools, a full-service spa, and water-based activities on Mission Bay.
When Keating Hotel wins: Choose Keating if you want historic character, Pininfarina-designed rooms, and immediate access to Gaslamp Quarter dining, nightlife, and downtown attractions in a compact boutique property.
When Hyatt Regency Mission Bay Spa and Marina wins: Choose the Hyatt for a larger property with multiple outdoor pools, on-site marina and watersports access, a full-service spa, and more meeting/event capacity for group stays.
Bottom line: Pick Keating for downtown, design-focused stays and proximity to San Diego's urban attractions; pick Hyatt Regency Mission Bay Spa and Marina for a resort experience on the water with more on-site amenities.
| Category | Keating Hotel | Hyatt Regency Mission Bay Spa and Marina |
|---|---|---|
| Overall vibe | Small, design-led boutique in a historic 1890 building | Large marina resort with resort-style amenities |
| Location | Gaslamp Quarter, downtown San Diego — walking distance to Petco Park and the Convention Center | Mission Bay waterfront — steps from Mission Bay and close to Mission Beach |
| Size (rooms) | 35 custom-designed 'stanzas' and several suites | 438 guestrooms |
| Ages / audience | All ages welcome (hotel policy: children allowed; various OTA notes on minimum check-in age) | |
| Pools / water access | No pool on site; in-room spa services available; nearby beaches require a short drive | Three outdoor pools, waterslide, marina and water-sport activities nearby |
| Restaurants & bars | No on-site full restaurant per the hotel's FAQ (guests walk to Gaslamp dining); some listings have referenced past tenants | Two restaurants plus a coffee shop/cafe and poolside bar (Red Marlin listed among dining options) |
| Spa & wellness | In-room and in-suite spa services; Fresca Spa Suite with whirlpool and steam shower | Full-service spa offering massages and reservations required |
| Meetings & events | About 2,500 sq ft of historic meeting space with multiple rooms (Gran Turismo, Maranello, Modena) | Conference center and multiple meeting rooms; ballroom / banquet facilities |
| Parking | Valet parking (in-and-out privileges); rates vary by booking source | Self and valet parking available (both subject to fees) |
| Pet policy | Pet-friendly rooms on request; fees and limits vary by OTA and source | Pet deposit and pet fees listed (service animals exempt) — fees apply |
Keating sits at 432 F Street in the heart of the Gaslamp Quarter, within walking distance of downtown attractions.
Keating is the practical pick for travelers who plan to spend time in downtown San Diego and want walkable access to nightlife and meetings.
Hyatt Regency Mission Bay Spa and Marina sits on Mission Bay with on-site marina access and a resort setting.
Hyatt Regency is better if you want a waterfront location and easy access to beach and bay activities rather than downtown nightlife.
Keating offers 35 custom-designed 'stanzas' and distinct suites in a boutique footprint.
Expect individualized, design-forward rooms with a boutique feel rather than standardized resort room types.
Hyatt Regency has a broad range of room types and suites across a 438-room property.
Hyatt gives you more room-type choices and predictable full-service hotel room amenities across a large property.
Keating advertises no on-site full restaurant and directs guests to Gaslamp Quarter dining next door.
If you want great variety on foot and nightlife after dinner, Keating’s downtown location is ideal; don’t expect multiple on-site restaurants.
Hyatt Regency lists two restaurants, a coffee shop/cafe and a poolside bar on property.
Hyatt suits travelers who prefer on-site dining and drinks without leaving the property.
Keating does not have an on-site pool; beach access requires a short drive.
Keating is a downtown hotel — if swimming or pool time is important, plan to visit nearby beaches or choose a different property.
Hyatt Regency provides resort-style water amenities, including three outdoor pools and a waterslide.
Hyatt is the clear choice for guests who prioritize pools and on-site water activities.
Keating focuses on in-room spa services and access to downtown nightlife rather than a public spa.
Keating is right for travelers who want private, in-room treatments and immediate access to downtown evening options.
Hyatt Regency offers a full-service spa, health club, and resort recreation after dark.
Choose the Hyatt for a conventional spa program and resort-style nighttime socializing without leaving the property.

Keating Hotel — steps from Gaslamp restaurants, bars, theatres, and Petco Park.

Hyatt Regency Mission Bay — three outdoor pools, waterslide, and on-site marina access.

Keating Hotel — Pininfarina redesign in a restored 1890 building and individually styled rooms.

Hyatt Regency Mission Bay — extensive meeting space, many rooms and family-friendly resort features.
Keating Hotel is in the Gaslamp Quarter and within easy walking distance of Petco Park and the San Diego Convention Center.
Hyatt Regency Mission Bay Spa and Marina — it lists three outdoor pools, a waterslide, and marina access for water sports.
No. Keating's official information states there is no on-site full restaurant; guests use the nearby Gaslamp dining options.
Both properties accept guests of all ages (neither property is adults-only).
Hyatt Regency has extensive conference and meeting facilities; Keating offers about 2,500 sq ft of historic meeting space suitable for smaller, design-focused events.
Explore how Keating Hotel stacks up against other hotels nearby:
vs. sites like Expedia, Hotels.com and other OTAs ·