
Keating Hotel
Best for couples and solo travelers who want a compact, design-focused stay in the Gaslamp Quarter within easy walking distance of downtown nightlife and Petco Park.
Prices in other currencies are estimates. You’re charged in USD.
Keating Hotel is a small, historic boutique in the Gaslamp Quarter for travelers who want a compact, design-forward downtown stay. Marriott Marquis San Diego Marina is a large waterfront convention hotel for travelers who need marina views, event space, and resort-style amenities.
Updated · about 0.8 km apart

Best for couples and solo travelers who want a compact, design-focused stay in the Gaslamp Quarter within easy walking distance of downtown nightlife and Petco Park.

Best for groups, convention attendees, and travelers who want marina or bay views plus large meeting facilities and resort-style amenities.
When Keating Hotel wins: choose Keating if you want a small, historic boutique building in the heart of the Gaslamp Quarter with loft-style 'stanzas,' personalized service, and immediate access to downtown dining and nightlife.
When Marriott Marquis San Diego Marina wins: choose Marriott Marquis if you need large meeting or banquet facilities, a wider range of room types (including bay-view rooms and suites), outdoor pools, on-site dining and bars, and easy access to the waterfront and marina.
Bottom line: pick Keating for a compact, design-driven downtown base and a historic atmosphere; pick the Marriott Marquis for scale — more rooms, more on-site amenities, and facilities for conventions and groups.
| Category | Keating Hotel | Marriott Marquis San Diego Marina |
|---|---|---|
| Overall vibe | Small historic boutique, Italian design influence (Pininfarina), intimate | Large waterfront convention hotel, business and event scale |
| Location | Gaslamp Quarter, inside downtown nightlife district, steps to Horton Plaza | Downtown waterfront near San Diego Marina and Seaport Village |
| Size (rooms) | 35 custom-designed rooms and 9 suites | Not published |
| Building / age | Historic 1890 building, redesigned 2007 by Pininfarina | Modern large-scale hotel built/expanded as a waterfront landmark (4-star) |
| Pools / waterfront | No on-site pool; nearest public beaches and waterfront require transport | Outdoor swimming pool(s) and marina/bay views |
| Restaurants & bars | No on-site restaurant (hotel points guests to Gaslamp dining) | Multiple on-site restaurants, bar, coffee shop and room service |
| Spa / wellness | In-room and in-suite spa/massage services; Fresca Spa Suite with whirlpool and steam | On-site spa services (supplier listing includes body scrub, body wrap, hot tub, yoga room) |
| Meeting & event space | About 2,500 sq ft of historic meeting space (Gran Turismo, Maranello, Modena, Foyer) | Large meeting/banquet facilities suitable for conventions and groups |
| Parking | Valet parking with in-and-out privileges; height restrictions apply | On-site accessible self parking and valet options |
| Family / age policy | All-ages property (hotel policy: children allowed; some OTAs vary on min age) | |
Keating sits at 432 F Street in the Gaslamp Quarter, inside the city’s main restaurant and nightlife district.
Choose Keating for walkable downtown nightlife and immediate Gaslamp access.
Marriott Marquis San Diego Marina is on the downtown waterfront at 333 West Harbor Drive, adjacent to the San Diego Marina and Seaport Village.
Choose Marriott Marquis for waterfront access and proximity to marina and convention venues.
Keating offers 35 custom-designed loft-style 'stanzas' and a handful of distinctive suites.
Keating is best if you want a boutique, design-forward room in downtown San Diego.
Marriott Marquis offers many room types from city-view rooms to bay-view deluxe rooms and suites.
Marriott Marquis fits travelers who want more room-type variety and bay-view options.
Keating does not operate an on-site restaurant and points guests to Gaslamp dining within walking distance.
Keating is a good base if you plan to eat out in the Gaslamp district every night.
Marriott Marquis provides on-site restaurants, a bar, a coffee shop, and room service.
Marriott Marquis is better if you prefer on-site dining and event catering.
Keating does not have an on-site pool and recommends nearby beaches and waterfronts for swimming.
Don’t book Keating if you want hotel pools; use it for nearby city and beach access instead.
Marriott Marquis lists outdoor swimming pool(s), hot tub, and water-sport/tour options tied to its marina location.
Marriott Marquis suits travelers who want on-site pools and easy marina access.
Keating focuses on in-room spa services and boutique wellness touches rather than a full spa facility.
Pick Keating for private in-room treatments and immediate access to downtown nightlife.
Marriott Marquis offers a wider wellness and activity program, plus on-site fitness and salon services listed.
Marriott Marquis is better for on-site wellness facilities and more evening options without leaving the property.

Keating Hotel — steps from the Gaslamp Quarter’s restaurants, bars, and Horton Plaza.

Marriott Marquis — large meeting/banquet facilities and proximity to the San Diego Convention Center.

Marriott Marquis — outdoor pools, marina views and easy access to waterfront activities.

Keating Hotel — historic 1890 building redesigned by Pininfarina with individually styled stanzas and suites.
Both are within a short drive, but Keating is in the Gaslamp Quarter and about a 15-minute walk to Petco Park.
Marriott Marquis San Diego Marina has outdoor swimming pool(s); Keating Hotel does not have an on-site pool.
Marriott Marquis is geared to conventions and large events with extensive meeting space and on-site facilities; Keating is smaller and better for boutique meetings.
No — Keating does not operate an on-site restaurant and directs guests to nearby Gaslamp dining.
Explore how Keating Hotel stacks up against other hotels nearby:
vs. sites like Expedia, Hotels.com and other OTAs ·