
Keating Hotel
Best for short downtown stays when you want immediate access to Gaslamp restaurants, nightlife, and Petco Park.
Prices in other currencies are estimates. You’re charged in USD.
Keating Hotel is a 35-room boutique in San Diego’s Gaslamp Quarter for travelers who want a compact, design-forward downtown base. Loews Coronado Bay Resort is a 4-star bayfront resort on Coronado’s Silver Strand for guests seeking resort amenities, pools, and waterfront seclusion.
Updated · about 8.7 mi (14 km) apart

Best for short downtown stays when you want immediate access to Gaslamp restaurants, nightlife, and Petco Park.

Best for travelers who want a full-service waterfront resort with pools, a full spa, and meeting/event facilities.
When Keating Hotel wins: Choose Keating if you want a small, design-focused downtown hotel within walking distance of the Gaslamp Quarter, convention center, and Petco Park; it’s a better fit for short urban stays and meeting/event space on a boutique scale.
When Loews Coronado Bay Resort wins: Choose Loews Coronado Bay Resort if you want resort-scale amenities — multiple pools, hot tubs, a full-service spa, on-site recreation and shuttle access to beaches — and prefer a quieter bayfront location away from downtown nightlife.
Bottom line: Pick Keating for compact downtown convenience and boutique style; pick Loews Coronado Bay Resort for resort facilities, waterfront access, and larger meeting/event capacities.
| Category | Keating Hotel | Loews Coronado Bay Resort |
|---|---|---|
| Overall vibe | Boutique, design-forward urban hotel | Full-service waterfront resort |
| Location | Gaslamp Quarter, downtown San Diego (walkable to Petco Park & convention center) | Bayfront on Coronado’s Silver Strand (secluded waterfront setting) |
| Size (rooms) | 35 rooms (including 9 suites and specialty stanzas) | 439 guestrooms |
| Ages / audience | All ages allowed (hotel policy: children allowed; some OTAs note 18+ liability for bookings) | All ages allowed (not adults-only) |
| Pools & water access | No on-site pool; in-room spa services and a specialty Fresca Spa Suite | 3 outdoor pools, 2 hot tubs, complimentary beach shuttle; bay access and on-site boats |
| Restaurants & bars | No on-site full restaurant (hotel points guests to Gaslamp dining); Brick + Mortar referenced on some listings | On-site restaurant and 2 bars/lounges plus a poolside bar; room service (limited hours) |
| Spa & wellness | In-room/in-suite spa and massages (Fresca Spa Suite available); no public spa facilities listed | Full-service spa with massages, body treatments, facials; sauna and fitness facilities (24-hour) |
| Meetings & events | About 2,500 sq ft of historic meeting space; multiple small rooms (Gran Turismo, Maranello, Modena) | Large conference capability: 65,003 sq ft (18 meeting rooms) and banquet space |
| Parking | Valet parking (in/out privileges); nightly valet rates vary by source | Self parking and valet (both surcharge; listed fees on supplier listing) |
| Known for | Pininfarina-designed interiors and historic 1890 building; central nightlife access | Bayfront location on the Silver Strand, resort pools, and full-service spa |
Keating sits at 432 F Street in the Gaslamp Quarter, within easy walking distance of Petco Park, the convention center, restaurants, and nightlife.
Keating is best if you want immediate downtown access to dining, nightlife, and event venues.
Loews Coronado Bay Resort sits on Coronado’s Silver Strand with a bayfront location that separates it from downtown activity.
Loews is for travelers who prefer a waterfront resort setting and don’t need to be in the middle of downtown nightlife.
Keating has 35 custom-designed loft-style 'stanzas' and several suites with specialty options.
Choose Keating for boutique, design-led rooms and a few standout suites rather than a large variety of room categories.
Loews offers a wide range of room types and suites with many rooms offering pool, marina, or bay views.
Loews is the pick if you want many room choices, suites, and accessible room options across a large resort property.
Keating does not operate a full on-site restaurant and directs guests to hundreds of nearby Gaslamp options.
Keating is ideal for guests who want to explore the city’s food scene rather than rely on hotel restaurants.
Loews has an on-site restaurant, multiple bars/lounges, and poolside dining options.
If you want on-property dining and casual poolside service, Loews delivers a full-service F&B program.
Keating does not have an on-site pool; it focuses on in-room spa options and downtown access to beaches by short drive or ferry.
Keating is not a swim-focused property — pick it for city access rather than on-site aquatic amenities.
Loews Coronado Bay Resort lists three outdoor pools, two hot tubs, and a complimentary beach shuttle.
Loews is the clear choice for guests who want multiple pools, hot tubs, and easy beach access.
Keating offers in-room spa services and places you inside the Gaslamp nightlife district.
Keating gives private in-room wellness plus immediate access to downtown nightlife.
Loews has a full-service spa, 24-hour fitness facilities, and resort-style programming that skews quieter after dark.
Pick Loews for a dedicated spa and fitness offering and a quieter evening atmosphere.

Keating — walk out to Gaslamp restaurants, bars, and Petco Park in minutes.

Loews Coronado Bay Resort — multiple pools, hot tubs, and a beach shuttle put water access at the center of the stay.

Loews — extensive meeting space (18 meeting rooms and large conference square footage) for bigger events.

Keating — small number of custom 'stanzas,' Pininfarina redesign and historic 1890 building.
Keating is closer to Petco Park (about a 15-minute walk), making it the more convenient choice for attending a Padres game.
Loews Coronado Bay Resort has multiple outdoor pools, hot tubs, and a full-service spa. Keating offers in-room massages and a spa suite but no public hotel pool.
No — Keating does not operate a full on-site restaurant and directs guests to nearby Gaslamp dining options; Loews has on-site restaurant and bar options.
Both properties allow guests of all ages; Loews is not an adults-only property, and Keating’s policy confirms children are allowed.
Explore how Keating Hotel stacks up against other hotels nearby:
vs. sites like Expedia, Hotels.com and other OTAs ·