
Keating Hotel
Best for downtown nightlife, walkable restaurants, and compact boutique design.
Prices in other currencies are estimates. You’re charged in USD.
Keating Hotel is a small historic boutique in the Gaslamp Quarter, good for travelers who want a downtown, design-forward base steps from nightlife and the convention center. Kona Kai Resort & Spa, a Noble House Resort is a Shelter Island marina resort with a full-service spa and waterfront activities — read this if you prefer a quieter waterside stay with resort amenities.
Updated · about 4 km apart

Best for downtown nightlife, walkable restaurants, and compact boutique design.

Best for waterfront relaxation, on-site spa treatments, and watersport options.
When Keating Hotel wins: choose Keating if you want to be in the middle of the Gaslamp Quarter within easy walking distance of Petco Park, convention venues, bars, and restaurants and prefer a small, design-forward boutique property with historic character.
When Kona Kai wins: pick Kona Kai if you want a quieter waterfront setting with lakeside-style resort amenities — an outdoor pool, private beach access, a full spa, boating and watersport rentals — while still being within a short drive of downtown San Diego.
Bottom line: Keating is the right choice for an urban, compact boutique stay centered on downtown attractions; Kona Kai is the better option for travelers wanting resort facilities and a marina/beachfront vibe on Shelter Island.
| Category | Keating Hotel | Kona Kai Resort & Spa, a Noble House Resort |
|---|---|---|
| Overall vibe | Urban historic boutique, Italian-influenced design | Marina resort with spa and watersport focus |
| Location | 432 F Street, Gaslamp Quarter (downtown) | 1551 Shelter Island Drive (Shelter Island marina) |
| Size / rooms | 35 rooms across 4 floors (including 9 suites) | Not published |
| Ages / policy | All ages welcome (hotel policy: children allowed; up to 14 stay free on existing bedding) | All ages welcome (not adults-only) |
| Pools / beach | No on-site pool | Outdoor swimming pool(s) and private beach / waterside access |
| Restaurants & bars | No on-site restaurant (many nearby dining options in Gaslamp) | On-site restaurants and bars (poolside bar and waterside lounge listed) |
| Spa & wellness | In-room and suite spa/massage services (Fresca Spa Suite available) | Full-service spa, massage, hot tub, steam room and salon |
| Known for | Historic 1890 building redesigned by Pininfarina; boutique stanzas and event spaces | Shelter Island marina location with boating and watersports rentals |
| Parking | Valet parking with in/out privileges (fees vary); height restrictions apply | On-site car park (charges apply) and valet parking options |
| Business & events | About 2,500 sq ft of historic meeting/event space across multiple rooms | Meeting/banquet facilities and indoor event venues |
Keating sits in downtown San Diego’s Gaslamp Quarter, steps from restaurants, nightlife and the convention center.
Keating puts you in the heart of downtown and close to most city attractions on foot.
Kona Kai sits on Shelter Island’s marina strip, oriented toward waterfront access and a quieter setting than downtown.
Kona Kai trades downtown energy for a sheltered marina location and water access.
Keating offers custom-designed loft-style 'stanzas' and a handful of named suites in a small property.
Keating’s rooms emphasize design, historic character and a boutique feel rather than resort-scale options.
Kona Kai provides a wider set of guestroom types with bay and marina views and suite options.
Kona Kai has room choices geared to waterfront views and resort comfort; exact room total is not published.
Keating does not operate an on-site restaurant; it relies on Gaslamp dining nearby.
Choose Keating if you want immediate access to many independent restaurants rather than hotel dining.
Kona Kai lists on-site restaurants and bars, including a poolside bar and waterside lounge.
Kona Kai lets you eat and drink on property with views of the marina or pool.
Keating focuses on boutique urban accommodations and does not provide a pool.
If a pool or beach is a must, Keating is not the right pick.
Kona Kai’s signature appeal is its waterfront setting with an outdoor pool and private beach access.
Kona Kai is preferable for travelers who want to swim, sun and take part in marina activities without leaving the property.
Keating provides in-room spa services and a spa-suite option rather than a public spa facility.
Keating is for guests who prefer private, in-room treatments and immediate access to downtown nightlife.
Kona Kai has a full-service spa plus fitness and shared wellness spaces.
Kona Kai suits travelers seeking a resort wellness program combined with waterfront recreation.

Keating — walk to Gaslamp restaurants, bars, theaters and Petco Park in minutes.

Kona Kai — full spa, hot tub, outdoor pool and private beach or waterside access.

Keating — 1890 building redesigned by Pininfarina with custom 'stanza' rooms and named suites.

Kona Kai — boating and watersport rentals available directly from the resort.
Keating is in the Gaslamp Quarter within easy walking distance of Petco Park and the convention center; Kona Kai is on Shelter Island and requires a short drive or taxi ride into downtown.
Kona Kai has outdoor pool(s) and private beach/waterside access; Keating does not have an on-site pool.
Keating offers in-room and suite-based spa and massage services (the Fresca Spa Suite is a specialty in-suite wellness option) rather than a public, full-service spa.
Both properties accept guests of all ages; Kona Kai is not adults-only, and Keating’s policy states children are allowed (with specific rules for children up to 14).
Explore how Keating Hotel stacks up against other hotels nearby:
vs. sites like Expedia, Hotels.com and other OTAs ·