
Keating Hotel
Best for couples and solo travelers who want boutique design, a Gaslamp address, and easy walking access to downtown nightlife and Petco Park.
Prices in other currencies are estimates. You’re charged in USD.
Keating Hotel is a small, design-forward boutique in the Gaslamp Quarter housed in an 1890 building — ideal for travelers who want a compact, walkable downtown base. Hilton San Diego Bayfront is a large bayfront convention hotel beside Petco Park — a better pick for conference delegates, families, or guests who want waterfront views and resort-style facilities.
Updated · about 0.9 km apart

Best for couples and solo travelers who want boutique design, a Gaslamp address, and easy walking access to downtown nightlife and Petco Park.

Best for conference attendees, guests wanting waterfront views, and travelers who want on-site resort amenities (pool, fitness, meeting space).
When Keating Hotel wins: Choose Keating if you want a compact, design-led boutique stay in the heart of the Gaslamp Quarter, easy walking access to restaurants and nightlife, and a historic building with a small number of custom 'stanza' rooms.
When Hilton San Diego Bayfront wins: Pick Hilton San Diego Bayfront if you need large-capacity meeting and event space, a waterfront location beside Petco Park and the convention center, on-site pool and fitness facilities, and multiple dining/lounge options.
Bottom line: Keating is the downtown boutique for a neighborhood-focused stay; Hilton Bayfront is the large, full-service waterfront hotel for events, families, and guests prioritizing resort-style amenities and convention access.
| Category | Keating Hotel | Hilton San Diego Bayfront |
|---|---|---|
| Overall vibe | Small boutique, Italian design influence, historic building | Large, modern bayfront convention hotel |
| Location | In the Gaslamp Quarter at 432 F St; doorstep to restaurants and nightlife | On the downtown waterfront at 1 Park Blvd, beside the San Diego Convention Center and near Petco Park |
| Size (rooms) | 35 custom-designed 'stanzas' across four floors | 1,190 guestrooms (supplier listing) |
| Event & meeting space | About 2,500 sq ft (several small meeting rooms; Gran Turismo, Maranello, Modena) | ~165,000 sq ft of conference center and meeting rooms |
| Pools & hot tubs | No on-site pool | Outdoor pool(s) and at least one hot tub |
| Restaurants & bars | No on-site full-service restaurant per hotel's FAQ; Gaslamp dining within easy walk | On-site Californian restaurant (Hudson & Nash) plus bars and poolside bar |
| Spa & wellness | In-room and in-suite spa/massage services; Fresca Spa Suite with whirlpool/steam | On-site spa facilities listed (wheelchair accessible) and 24-hour fitness options |
| Accessibility & family policy | All-ages property; not wheelchair accessible for most rooms (contact hotel for details) | Family-friendly; accessible public spaces and services listed |
| Parking | Valet parking with in/out privileges (rates vary by source); height restrictions | Self- and valet parking available for a surcharge |
| Known for | Historic Pininfarina redesign, boutique loft-style stanzas, Gaslamp location | Waterfront location, convention and meeting capacity, resort-style amenities |
Keating sits in the middle of the Gaslamp Quarter at 432 F Street, a short walk to dining, nightlife and Petco Park.
Keating is best if you want to be in the Gaslamp's dining and nightlife scene.
Hilton San Diego Bayfront sits on the downtown waterfront beside the convention center and within walking distance of Petco Park.
Hilton is the more convenient choice for conventions, waterfront access, and event proximity.
Keating’s inventory is intentionally small and design-focused, with 35 custom stanzas and a few suites.
Keating emphasizes boutique design and a small-room experience rather than standardized large-hotel rooms.
Hilton San Diego Bayfront offers a large, standardized room inventory suitable for groups and conventions.
Hilton has the capacity and room variety that convention groups and larger parties need.
Keating does not operate a full on-site restaurant; the Gaslamp Quarter provides extensive nearby choices.
If you want neighborhood dining options within steps, Keating’s location is an advantage.
Hilton has on-site dining and multiple bars, including Hudson & Nash with waterfront views.
Hilton offers more on-site dining and bar choices, useful for event groups or guests preferring to stay on property.
Keating does not have an on-site pool; its standout amenities are the historic setting and in-room spa options.
Keating focuses on room-level amenities and neighborhood access rather than pool or resort facilities.
Hilton provides outdoor pool facilities and poolside amenities as part of its waterfront property offerings.
Hilton’s pool and waterfront position are key draws for guests wanting resort-style amenities in downtown San Diego.
Keating’s wellness focus is primarily in-room spa treatments and a specialty spa suite.
Keating is for guests who want private in-room treatments and to step out for nightlife.
Hilton offers on-site spa and fitness facilities and is connected to the downtown nightlife and convention scene.
Hilton serves guests who want on-site wellness facilities plus easy access to downtown entertainment.

Keating Hotel — for travelers who want a small, design-forward hotel in the Gaslamp Quarter.

Hilton San Diego Bayfront — for meeting planners and attendees needing large conference space and proximity to the convention center.

Hilton San Diego Bayfront — offers bayfront location, pool, and multiple on-site dining options.

Keating Hotel — located steps from Gaslamp restaurants, bars, and Horton Plaza shopping.
Hilton San Diego Bayfront is immediately adjacent to the Convention Center; Keating is a roughly 10–15 minute walk.
No — Keating does not have an on-site pool; Hilton has outdoor pool(s) and hot tub(s).
Both properties accept guests of all ages. Keating’s policies note children up to 14 may stay free on existing bedding; Hilton is listed as family-friendly in supplier materials.
Hilton San Diego Bayfront — it has large-scale conference space (about 165,000 sq ft) and extensive meeting facilities.
Explore how Keating Hotel stacks up against other hotels nearby:
vs. sites like Expedia, Hotels.com and other OTAs ·